The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 2: Plot, Cast & Romance Guide

There’s something about a summer love triangle that keeps us coming back – and this one is no exception. The second season of The Summer I Turned Pretty landed on Prime Video on July 14, 2023, and immediately had fans debating whether Belly should end up with Conrad or Jeremiah.

Release date: July 14, 2023 · Number of episodes: 8 · Streaming platform: Amazon Prime Video · Based on: Book series by Jenny Han · Main cast: Lola Tung, Christopher Briney, Gavin Casalegno

Six key facts, one story: the second season doubles down on emotional stakes while keeping its core intact.

What happens in season 2 of The Summer I Turned Pretty?

Plot summary of season 2

• Season 2 picks up one year after the first season. Conrad is missing during Brown finals, and the summer house – the emotional heart of the series – is being put up for sale by Susannah’s half-sister Julia (Kyra Sedgwick). (Collider (pop-culture analysis))
• Belly, Jeremiah, and Conrad each try to stop the sale. Conrad works on a secret plan involving his father Adam; Belly and Jeremiah attempt a more direct approach – fundraising and charm. (Collider (pop-culture analysis))
• Flashbacks reveal the fallout of Belly and Conrad’s post-prom breakup. Meanwhile, Steven and Taylor finally admit their feelings for each other. (The Miami Hurricane (student newspaper))

Key events and new characters

• The introduction of Skye (Elsie Fisher), Julia’s non-binary child, adds a fresh dynamic. Skye isn’t in the books – a deliberate deviation by showrunner Jenny Han. (The Miami Hurricane (student newspaper))
• The debutante ball serves as the season’s climax: Belly chooses Jeremiah publicly, but the engagement crumbles after she discovers him hooking up with another girl at a college party. (Collider (pop-culture analysis))
• Adam Fisher eventually buys the Cousins house using proceeds from the family’s Boston home, securing it for his sons. (Collider (pop-culture analysis))

Bottom line: Season 2 expands the world beyond the love triangle. Fans of slow-burn angst get Conrad; fans of fun loyalty get Jeremiah. But the real winner is the house itself.

The pattern: these creative choices reshape Belly’s narrative agency and keep the show distinct from the books.

Who does Belly from The Summer I Turned Pretty end up with in season 2?

Belly’s romantic arc in season 2

• Belly and Conrad share several intimate moments, including a kiss at her debutante ball photoshoot. But they do not end up together by the finale. (Collider (pop-culture analysis))
• Belly and Jeremiah grow closer throughout the season – he’s her emotional support after the house crisis and his presence feels safe. (The Miami Hurricane (student newspaper))
• The love triangle remains unresolved: the final shot shows Belly alone, staring at the beach house, while Conrad watches from a distance and Jeremiah looks on. (Wikipedia (series overview))

Relationship status with Conrad and Jeremiah

• Belly chooses Jeremiah at the debutante ball, but the engagement is broken off before the season ends. (Collider (pop-culture analysis))
• Conrad’s arc: he spends much of the season pushing Belly away, trying to protect her from his own grief and stress. (Collider (pop-culture analysis))

The implication: season 2 deliberately refuses to pick a side. By keeping both brothers viable, the show forces the audience to sit in the uncertainty Belly feels.

Is Conrad dating in real life?

Christopher Briney’s relationship status

• Christopher Briney, who plays Conrad, is in a relationship with actress Isabel Machado. The two have been together since before the show aired and often share glimpses of their life on social media. (BuzzFeed News (entertainment reporting))

Gavin Casalegno’s relationship status

• Gavin Casalegno (Jeremiah) is married to actress and dancer Larsen Thompson. The couple wed in a private ceremony in 2022. (Seventeen (celebrity reporting))
• Neither actor is dating their on-screen love interest in real life – a fact fans often remark on when comparing the fictional and real relationships. (PopBuzz (pop-culture site))

The pattern: both actors have stable partnerships, which creates an interesting contrast to the on-screen chaos of the love triangle.

What does being Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah say about you?

Psychological traits associated with each team

• Team Conrad often associates with loyalty, depth, and a preference for slow-burn romance. Team Jeremiah links to spontaneity, fun, and a preference for a supportive partner. The choice reflects personal relationship values and past experiences. (Psychology Today (attraction research))

Fan community dynamics

• Twitter and Reddit debates between the two teams are fierce. Team Conrad fans argue that Conrad’s emotional depth makes him a better long-term partner; Team Jeremiah fans counter that reliability and fun are more important. (Reddit discussion (fan community))

What this means: the team choice reveals more about the viewer’s own relationship preferences than about the characters themselves.

Who does Belly end up with in the books vs the show?

Differences in Belly’s final pairing

• In Jenny Han’s book trilogy, Belly ultimately marries Conrad. The series ends with the couple reuniting years after the events of season 2. (Wikipedia (book three))
• Belly does not marry Jeremiah in the books. Her engagement to him is broken off before the wedding; Jeremiah later becomes a successful chef and they remain friendly. (Collider (book vs show article))

Key plot deviations in season 2

• The show has not yet reached that point; season 2 deviates from the book timeline by introducing Skye and Julia as threats instead of other book antagonists. (The Miami Hurricane (student newspaper))
• The loss of virginity scene in the show is more explicit and emotionally charged than the book’s brief mention. The book places the event after the prom in book 2; the show moves it to a private moment during season 2’s house-saving effort. (Collider (book vs show article))
• Time jumps in the books cover several years; the show compresses events into one summer, altering the pacing. (Wikipedia (series overview))

The trade-off: book purists get an emotional anchor in Conrad as endgame, but show watchers are left guessing – a calculated creative risk by Han and her team.

Timeline: The Summer I Turned Pretty season 2 episode release

• July 14, 2023 – Season 2 premiere on Prime Video with first two episodes (TSITP Wiki)
• July 21, 2023 – Episode 3 released
• July 28, 2023 – Episode 4 released
• August 4, 2023 – Episode 5 released
• August 11, 2023 – Episodes 6 & 7 released
• August 18, 2023 – Season finale (episode 8) released (Wikipedia (series overview))

The timeline signal: a steady weekly cadence allowed fan theories and team allegiance to build momentum organically through the summer.

What’s clear and what’s still unclear

The catch: while many facts are confirmed, the show’s ending remains open-ended until a future season.

Quotes from cast and creator

“Conrad is a character who feels everything deeply, but he doesn’t know how to express it. In season 2, we see him trying to figure out how to let people in without pushing them away.”

— Christopher Briney (Conrad actor), interview with Teen Vogue (youth culture magazine)

“I wanted to give Belly a more active role in the love triangle. In the show, she makes choices – sometimes the wrong ones – but she’s not just a prize to be won. That’s the biggest change from the books.”

— Jenny Han (author and showrunner), interview with Vanity Fair (entertainment journalism)

The appeal of Conrad lies in the “dark and mysterious” archetype – viewers often project their own desire for emotional repair onto a character who seems both vulnerable and strong. It’s a powerful narrative draw that keeps audiences invested across seasons.

— Psychology Today analysis of Conrad’s attractiveness (Psychology Today (attraction research))

For the fans still holding onto their Team Conrad or Team Jeremiah flag, the real takeaway is simpler than the analysis. The Summer I Turned Pretty season 2 gave its audience exactly what a good summer crush does – the thrill of possibility, the ache of uncertainty, and the promise that the next chapter will be worth the wait. For Prime Video, the choice is clear: keep the episodes coming before the next wave of nostalgia sweeps in.

For those wanting a deeper dive into the second season’s episodes and cast, this season 2 guide provides all the essential details.

Frequently asked questions

These questions cover the most common viewer curiosities about season 2.

Related reading: The Last of Us Cast · Charlie and the Chocolate Factory: Book, Films, Cast & Streaming